Friday, October 17, 2014

On bhedabheda


 I didnt know about this cult before sometime.I only thought that there are two sects
visishtadvaita dvaita.But this I came to know much later.This is chaitanya cult which has krishna as god.They have bhagavata,gita as main scriptures.While ramanuja's visishtadvaita says the world is god's body,the atma becomes a part of brahman or vishnu.It attains the state of vishnu as mukti.Madhwa who created dvaita says god or ishwara created jiva and jiva is separate from
ishwara,and mukt means jiva stays in the company of ishwara and
serves him.Though this has been modified by later followers.This behdabheda is gods and his
energies or sun and its rays.So its admitting abheda and bheda like energy is same and different from god,and sun's rays are same and different from sun.So far so good.But before god released his energies,that is before creation what was the state of jiva.It has to be god,as god alone must have existed.So advaita is proved.
Before sun released his rays,there was only sun.So jiva cant be separate from god or brahman.It cant attain an inferior position than what it was before.So this bhedabheda is false theory to justfy their krishna as superior god,and refusing sayujya and maintaning an individual identity.
Even from devotional point of view sayuja cant be denied.The atma cant remian separated from brahman.



























2 comments:

  1. All living entities are 'spirit souls' that is 'atma'.We are eternally separated part and parcel of the Supreme Soul Sri Krsna.Sri Krsna is eternal and therefore we too are eternal.We His 'tatastha shakti'that is,'marginal potency'.The 'spirit soul' can never 'merge' into the Supreme Brahman.'na tva eva aham jatu nasam,na twam neme janadipaha,na chaiva na bhavishymaha sarve vayam ataha param'.

    ReplyDelete

  2. There is only one consciousness.It manifests as the world.You need a certain level of knowledge before you can comment on these things.

    ReplyDelete